A controversial scene does not scandalize readers because of the topic. It scandalizes them when the writer handles the topic badly: the detail is there for shock, the characters have no interiority, or the story stops to tell the reader what to think. The test is simple. Ask what you want the scene to do to the reader, then ask what it actually does on the page. If those two answers match, write it.
Ah, the allure of controversy! There’s an undeniable charm in writing something that gets the masses talking. However, there’s a fine line between creating thought-provoking content and flat-out scandalizing your readers. Where’s the balance? Let’s delve into the art and science of writing engaging, provocative content without crossing that line.
1. Intent vs. Impact
Before you put pen to paper or fingers to keyboard, ponder this: why do you want to discuss a potentially controversial topic? If it’s just to stir the pot and gain temporary notoriety, it might be time to reassess. The most impactful controversial pieces are those grounded in genuine intent, not a mere wish for the spotlight.
Tip to Try: Always question the why. If your intent aligns with bringing awareness or creating dialogue around a crucial issue, you’re on the right track.
2. Know Your Audience
Understanding your readers is pivotal. This doesn’t mean avoiding topics that might challenge them but ensuring that your approach is sensitive and tailored to their sensibilities.
Tip to Try: Picture your most loyal reader. How would they react to your piece? Shocked, intrigued, or offended? Use this mental exercise to gauge your approach.
3. Research, Research, Research
There’s nothing worse than diving into a controversial topic ill-prepared. It’s a sure-fire way to lose credibility. Equip yourself with facts and multiple perspectives to give a well-rounded view.
Tip to Try: Don’t rely solely on popular opinion. Dive deep into scholarly articles, firsthand accounts, and diverse sources to gain a comprehensive understanding.
4. Be Ready for Feedback (and Backlash)
Let’s be real. No matter how well-intentioned and researched your piece is, there will always be naysayers. It’s essential to be mentally prepared for the feedback, both constructive and negative.
Tip to Try: Consider setting up a feedback mechanism where readers can share their views. Engage with them constructively, without getting defensive. When the feedback does arrive, the harder skill is handling negative feedback without getting defensive.
5. Avoid Sensationalism
While it might be tempting to use provocative headlines or exaggerations, it’s best to steer clear of sensationalism. It undermines the legitimacy of your work and often misleads readers.
Tip to Try: Craft your headlines and content honestly. Let the genuine weight of the topic pull readers in, rather than cheap theatrics.
6. Reflect & Evolve
Your relationship with controversy shouldn’t be a one-and-done affair. Reflect on the feedback, understand the areas you could’ve handled better, and evolve. Every piece is a learning opportunity.
Tip to Try: Periodically review your controversial pieces. Would you approach the topic the same way today? Continuous reflection keeps your writing relevant and grounded.
What actually scandalizes readers
Much of the backlash writers fear does not come from the subject. It comes from four scene-level choices, and each one is fixable in a revision pass.
- The detail is there for shock. A violent or sexual beat described in more detail than the story needs reads as the writer enjoying it, not the character living it.
- The character has no interiority. If the reader never gets inside the head of the person the scene happens to, the scene is an event, not an experience, and it is easy to accuse of being callous.
- The other side is a strawman. A character who exists only to be wrong tells the reader the book is arguing with them, not with the character.
- The moral is announced. A scene that ends by telling the reader what to feel has stopped trusting them, and readers notice.
Before and after: the same scene, handled two ways
Here is an example scene, not from any real book. A character witnesses a public act of violence against a stranger.
Handled badly: the paragraph lingers on the blood and the sound of the impact, the crowd reacts as one anonymous mass, and the chapter closes with a line explaining that violence is always wrong.
Handled well: the paragraph stays close to the viewpoint character, who does not look away but also cannot move. The crowd is two or three specific people doing specific things. The chapter closes on what the character does next, or fails to do, and the reader supplies the judgment.
The topic did not change. The intent did not change. Only the handling changed, and that is the difference between a scene readers argue about and a scene readers resent.
The reader contract
Every book makes a quiet promise in its first pages about what kind of experience it is. A reader who picks up a thriller expects violence; a reader who picks up a cozy mystery does not. Breaking that promise is not brave, it is a bait and switch, and it is a common reason a controversial scene lands as a betrayal rather than a shock. Decide what you are promising early, then keep the promise.
If your scene’s real job is to leave the reader unsettled, that is a case for leaving questions unanswered rather than answering them for the reader.
In Closing:
Dabbling in controversy is not for the faint-hearted. It’s a challenging realm, fraught with pitfalls but also rich with potential. When handled with care, sensitivity, and genuine intent, controversial pieces can spark meaningful dialogues and drive change. So, go ahead, dip your toes into those turbulent waters, but always navigate with your moral compass in hand.
Stick around as we dive into more intricate facets of the writing world. It’s a wild ride, and we’re in it together. Happy writing, and remember, it’s all about the journey, not just the destination!
Free writing tools to try next
- Slop Detector: catch clichés and AI tells.
- Beta Reader: get honest reader-style feedback.
- Rate My Prose: score your writing and find the weak spots.