How to write dialogue: make every line do at least two jobs. It should move the scene forward and reveal something about the speaker, and if it only does one, cut it or change it. The rest of this page shows what that looks like in practice, with before/after lines, a subtext exercise, and the five fixes that turn talky scenes into tense ones.
Do you ever eavesdrop? Admit it! We’ve all leaned a smidge too close to that riveting conversation at the next café table. Not me, of course (wink). Dialogue in real life is messy, often roundabout, and sometimes it’s what’s not said that speaks volumes. So how do we emulate that in writing without putting readers to sleep?
Buckle up, writerly compatriots! We’re embarking on a journey through the melodious maze of dialogue.
Before and after: what a flat line looks like
Here is a scene doing one job only. Two characters say exactly what they mean, and the reader learns nothing they could not have guessed. It is an interview, and the candidate is late.
Before: “I’m sorry I’m late,” he said. “I know it looks bad. I really want this job.” “It’s fine,” she said. “Let’s get started.”
After: He came in with his coat still on. “Traffic was bad.” She looked at the coat, then at the clock. “It usually is.” He sat. “The thing is, I really want this job.” “I know,” she said, and opened the folder. “That’s what worries me.”
The after version does the same job with less said. Nobody names the problem, the coat and the clock carry it, and her last line tells the reader exactly what she thinks of a man who wants the job and still turns up late. That is subtext: the reader does the work, and because they do, they feel it.
Five fixes for dialogue that falls flat
1. The Power of Subtext
Real people often speak in subtext. We dodge, we hint, we imply. Our words are merely the tip of the iceberg.
Tip to Try: Craft a dialogue where characters are discussing something mundane (like tea), but they’re actually arguing about a deeper issue (like their relationship). If done right, the reader should feel the tension without the characters ever addressing the main problem directly.
2. Every Character Has a Voice
Each person sounds unique. They have different vocabularies, rhythms, and quirks. Ensure your characters don’t all sound like… well, like you.
Tip to Try: Write a dialogue without any dialogue tags or actions. If your characters are distinct enough, your reader should still be able to tell who’s speaking.
3. Keep it Snappy
Real-life conversations are filled with ums, ahs, and endless diversions. In writing, we don’t have that luxury.
Tip to Try: Cut, cut, and cut again. Once you’ve written a dialogue, challenge yourself to reduce it by half. It’s painful, I know, but your pacing will thank you.
4. Break it Up
Wall of text alert! Long, uninterrupted stretches of dialogue can overwhelm a reader. Use actions, internal thoughts, and setting descriptions to break up the dialogue and maintain pacing.
Tip to Try: Every time a character speaks, describe a small action they’re doing (fidgeting, glancing away, taking a sip of drink). This can also enhance the subtext!
5. Listen to Real Conversations
Go to a café, park, or any public place (not endorsing eavesdropping, but… research?). Listen to the rhythm, the interruptions, the overlaps, and the unspoken tensions.
Tip to Try: Transcribe a snippet of an overheard conversation. Then, adapt it into a dialogue in your story. Notice how much you have to edit to make it ‘fit’ but still sound ‘real’.
The fixes at a glance
| Problem in the draft | What the reader feels | The fix |
|---|---|---|
| Characters say exactly what they mean | No tension, nothing to work out | Put the real argument under a mundane topic (subtext) |
| Everyone sounds the same | Confusion about who is speaking | Strip the tags and check whether voices still differ |
| Lines run long and circle | Pacing sags, the reader skims | Cut the scene by half and see what survives |
| Walls of unattributed speech | The reader loses the room | Add small actions and setting beats between lines |
| Dialogue copies real speech too closely | It reads as noise, not story | Transcribe real talk, then edit it down until it fits |
A subtext exercise you can run tonight
Take a scene where two characters argue about the real problem. Rewrite it so they argue about something small instead: whose turn it is to lock up, what to order, whether the window should be open. Keep the real problem out of the words entirely. Then read it back and ask: could a reader tell what the fight is actually about from the pauses, the repeated words, and the small actions? If not, the subtext is not doing its job yet.
Muffled and overheard speech
Sometimes a character hears a conversation through a wall, a door, or a crowd, and the reader only gets fragments. Write it the way it sounds: half-lines, a name, a number, a tone rather than full sentences. The gap is the point. The reader fills in what was missed and worries about it, which is more useful to the story than a clean transcript nobody could actually have heard.
Once the scene works on the page, the next job is tightening every line, and this guide to editing dialogue walks through the cuts. For more advanced moves, these seven dialogue techniques go deeper into voice and subtext.
In Closing:
Dialogue is the heartbeat of your characters. It’s where their personalities, conflicts, desires, and quirks shine through. It’s a dance of words, a delicate balance between said and unsaid.
Join me next time when we explore “The End: Crafting a Conclusion that Stays with the Reader Long After the Book Closes”. Until then, let those characters chat away!
Free writing tools to try next
- Rate My Prose: score your writing and find the weak spots.
- Grammar Check: clean up grammar and punctuation.
- Editing Services: get professional editing help.