You want a plot idea you can start writing today. Here is the method: ask “what if?” about something real, smash two unrelated nouns together, and reverse the roles in a story you already know. Each step below comes with a worked example and a line that turns the idea into a premise you can draft from.
It’s every writer’s recurring nightmare – staring at that menacing, blinking cursor, racking the brain for a plot. Some call it writer’s block, others a temporary creative drought. Whatever the name, it’s daunting. But what if there’s a way to generate plot ideas, consistently, and with ease?
Welcome to the simple 3-step plot generation plan. Do all three steps in one sitting and you will have ten premises on paper. Then you pick one, which is the part most idea lists skip.
Step 1: Ask “What if?” about something real
Everything starts with a question, particularly the age-old, “What if?” It’s a magical phrase that leads you down unexpected alleys of thought. It’s the foundation of countless novels, films, and bedtime stories.
Tip to Try: Grab a newspaper, read a headline, and ask, “What if?” For instance, reading about a discovery of an old shipwreck might lead you to think, “What if the ship carried a secret society of time travelers?”
Worked example. Headline: a town votes to close its only library. What if the library was the one place in town where the dead could be spoken to, and the vote was pushed by someone who wanted a name silenced? That is no longer a headline with a twist; it is a story with a person in it who wants something.
Turn it into a premise. Name who wants what and who is in the way. “A librarian fights a council vote to keep a building open, because the dead who speak there include her mother, and the councilman leading the vote knows it.” One sentence, and you can already see the first scene.
Step 2: Collide two unrelated ideas
Innovation often arises from the intersection of unrelated domains. Why should plot creation be any different? Taking two unrelated ideas and smashing them together can yield intriguing, novel storylines.
Tip to Try: Write down ten random nouns on separate pieces of paper. Now, pull out two at a time. You’ve got “giraffe” and “piano”? Maybe your story revolves around a world where animals are trained in classical music, and there’s a giraffe prodigy causing a ruckus in the grand orchestras.
Worked example. “Lighthouse” and “divorce lawyer.” What if a divorce lawyer takes a case on a remote island reachable only through a lighthouse keeper, and the keeper has been quietly steering which couples ever get off the island? The collision gives you a setting, a gatekeeper, and a conflict in one move.
Turn it into a premise. The collision is only the setup. Add the opposition: who benefits if the character fails? A premise that reads “a lawyer visits an island” is a setting. A premise that reads “a lawyer discovers the keeper has been deciding which marriages survive, and the keeper knows why she left her own” is a plot.
Step 3: Reverse the roles
Nothing shakes up a plot like reversing roles. It’s a technique older than Shakespeare and as fresh as the morning headlines.
Tip to Try: Think of a story you love. Now, swap the roles of the protagonist and antagonist. How does the story change? Does the plot take a dark twist? Or perhaps a comedic turn? For example, in a reversed “Cinderella”, what if the stepmother was oppressed and Cinderella, the tyrant?
Worked example. Take the reversal one step further and ask who the reader would root for. In the reversed Cinderella, the stepmother is trying to protect her own daughters from a girl who has learned that charm and a fireplace get her anything. Now the ball is not a reward; it is a threat the stepmother has to stop.
Turn it into a premise. A reversal works when the new protagonist has a goal the old story never gave them. Write it as: “X has to stop Y from getting Z, because Z would cost X everything.” If you cannot fill in the “because,” the reversal is a gimmick, not a story.
Now pick one: the test that kills flat ideas
Ten ideas in twenty minutes is the easy part. The mistake that makes generated ideas feel flat is choosing the one with the best concept instead of the one with the most conflict. Run every candidate through two questions:
- What does the main character want, specifically, by the end of chapter one?
- Who is actively trying to stop them, and why does that person believe they are right?
The idea where you can answer both, in one sentence each, is the one to draft. The idea where the second answer is “nobody, really” is the one to leave in the notebook. If the idea stalls once you start drafting, the fixes for a narrative that goes off track are the next thing to read. Once you have a premise, the inciting incident guide shows you how to open the story with it.
The worksheet: ten ideas in twenty minutes
Copy this onto a sheet of paper and fill it in by hand. Screens invite editing; paper invites finishing.
- What if? (four lines). Write four headlines or things you saw this week, then one “what if?” sentence under each.
- Noun collision (three lines). List ten nouns, pair them at random, and keep the three pairs that make you ask a question.
- Role reversal (three lines). Pick three stories you know well and write the reversal as “X has to stop Y, because…”
- The pick (one line). From the ten, write the one premise where you can name what the character wants and who stops them.
Creativity, they say, is intelligence having fun. And generating plot ideas should be nothing short of a thrilling ride. With this 3-step plan in your writer’s toolkit, you’ll find yourself armed and ready to tackle the blank page. Remember, every idea, no matter how bizarre or unconventional, has the potential to become a riveting tale.
Don’t stifle those zany, out-of-the-box thoughts; they could be the makings of your next bestseller. Until next time, happy plotting!
Curious about more writing hacks? Stick around, and together we’ll navigate the ever-intriguing maze of storytelling!
Free writing tools to try next
- Rate My Prose: score your writing and find the weak spots.
- Beta Reader: get honest reader-style feedback.
- Editing Services: get professional editing help.